Guy who killed Toronto mosque caretaker not criminally liable

The guy accused of murdering a Muslim gentleman outside the house a Toronto mosque in 2020 has been identified not criminally accountable because of to a psychological disorder.

Guilherme (William) Von Neutegem, 37, had been experiencing a first-degree murder cost in the dying of 58-year-previous Mohamed-Aslim Zafis, a volunteer caretaker stabbed outside the Global Muslim Business mosque in Rexdale on Sept. 12, 2020.

Von Neutegem pleaded not guilty, and the Crown called qualified psychiatric proof that he was struggling from schizophrenia at the time.

The prosecution and defence jointly proposed that Von Neutegem be located not criminally responsible, according to a transient endorsement from Excellent Court docket Justice Peter Bawden on Friday.

A verdict of not criminally dependable does not imply Von Neutegem is unveiled from custody. He now falls less than the jurisdiction of the Ontario Critique Board, produced up of judges, attorneys, psychiatrists and associates of the general public.

The board will annually evaluation his scenario to figure out, amongst other things, whether or not he ought to be produced from a health-related establishment and underneath what situations.

Von Neutegem experienced been held in the Toronto South Detention Centre since his arrest, and has been using medication.

Initially reported by the Canadian Anti-Despise Community and verified by the Star shortly soon after the killing, various social media accounts linked to a man or woman with the exact name and spot as Von Neutegem contained white supremacist and neo-Nazi content and rhetoric.

The surprising slaying of Zafis prompted calls for action from Islamophobia, with advocates expressing irritation at the time that small had been completed to counter a wave of detest in the wake of the 2017 Quebec City mosque shooting that killed six worshippers.

Politicians which include Key Minister Justin Trudeau supplied condolences after Zafis’s dying. “We stand with Muslim communities against these kinds of hatred, which has no spot in Canada,” Trudeau tweeted in 2020.

In a sufferer effects assertion submitted with the court, Zafis’s only daughter, Bebi Zafis, described dropping both of those of her mom and dad back again to back again, with her mother dying in an incident in April 2020.

Their deaths have still left her in a constant condition of panic and anxiousness for herself and her loved kinds, she wrote.

She wrote that her father “often informed me that he liked assisting other people and that he obtained this sort of joy from doing the job in his group with his god by his side. He actually liked others with his full soul, and addressed other individuals with this sort of like and kindness.”

She added: “The steps of this guy having my father’s everyday living has experienced these a profound affect on me and my views of the entire world.”

When Von Neutegem was about 31 many years previous, he stated he started to communicate with “entities,” felt guided by them, and imagined of himself “as some sort of messenger … a reincarnation from the better planes,” in accordance to a December 2022 report from forensic psychiatrist Dr. Alina Iosif.

The report concluded he met the requirements for a prognosis of schizophrenia.

He afterwards began owning visions, and started to feel significantly isolated, emotion that men and women did not comprehend him, Iosif wrote. Eventually, a voice started telling him that it was “time for me to obtain someone to kill,” in accordance to the report.

He instructed the psychiatrist he started to actively glance for an individual to eliminate about one particular or two months in advance of his arrest.

On the early morning of Sept. 12, the day of Zafis’s killing, Von Neutegem experienced absent to a park and noticed a lady by itself, but determined not to go soon after her when other men and women approached, according to the report.

It’s when he was returning to his automobile, as it acquired dark outside the house, that he claimed he saw a male sitting down by yourself. He told the psychiatrist that he did not know the constructing was a mosque nor that the guy was Muslim. And that is when he stabbed Zafis.

Surveillance footage confirmed him stabbing Zafis once in the neck. The two did not have an interaction before the killing.

“I didn’t imagine I would get caught, the disorders ended up Ok and the universe would conspire in my favour due to the fact I was performing for the greater planes,” Von Neutegem explained to Iosif.

He denied any interest in white supremacy, nor that he had any dislike towards Muslims, the psychiatrist wrote.

At the time of the stabbing, Von Neutegem had been working as a cleaner in a squander management facility. When he was requested during the psychiatric assessment why he had pics of Nazi leaders on his cell mobile phone, he mentioned they were being intended as a joke, to use as a profile picture for his boss in his contact record.

Join THE Conversation

Conversations are thoughts of our readers and are issue to the Code of Perform. The Star
does not endorse these viewpoints.